Pup Corn Plus - Puffed Dog Treats with Prebiotics and Probiotics - Bacon & Peanut Butter (24oz) - Made in USA

Seemed stale. They were very hard and not fluffy. Didn't know how they were supposed to be. One dog won't eat them and the little dog, that eats anything, had a hard time chewing them, but will eat them.

Why not a perfect score? New double-sized bag is inconvenient and possibly reduces freshness (popped treats shrink into hard kernels).

My dog is on a restricted diet and she isn’t supposed to have any treats with beef or chicken. These fit the criteria and she seems to really like them. I used to be able to buy these in the pet stores but not any more. So it was Amazon to the rescue!

I've been giving these to my dog for years. She loves them and they are super low in calories.

I was looking forward to this product for my dog as he really needs a lower calorie treat and this had some good health benefits. But it was so hard when it came in that I couldn't break one in half if I tried and when he chewed it, I could hear that it was stale. And he is not a small dog. I am wondering if it was just the bag I got, or if others had this same problem?

We have 3 dogs & they all love these treats! They are just the right size, not a huge, heavy treat. We give them 2 each as rewards for doing tricks.

My dogs love these! They know the sound of the bag being opened and come running for them.

I can’t find them in the stores anymore? They were so much cheaper at Walmart.But dogs love them so I got them for Christmas.