Old Mother HubbardWellness P-Nuttier Dog Biscuits, Natural, Training Treats, Peanut Butter Flavor, Large Size, (3.3 Pound Bag)

I run through dog treats faster than I can blink. I suppose it's my own fault because I trained both of my dogs to ring a bell every time they need to go potty outside. When they come back, I usually give them a treat (positive reinforcement). They've both been taught this from day one when I got them as puppies @ 6 weeks old. Fast forward to today, my dogs are both 6 & 5 years old. I started out giving them full-sized dog treats, such as chicken jerky and medium sized biscuits by Old Mother Hubbard, but I started to notice it was getting expensive. If you let your dogs out several times a day, this can add up. So I started cutting the chicken jerky in bite sized pieces and breaking the biscuits in half... But still, it wasn't very time or cost efficient... So that's when I started shopping around for other treats.So a few years ago at my local pet store, I noticed that Milk Bone came out with the Milk Bone Mini's (Milk-Bone Mini's Flavor Snacks Dog Biscuits, 15-Ounce (Pack of 6)). It's a relatively new product because I never seen them before in my 6 years of dog ownership. Since Amazon was my go-to shopping retailer, I checked but Amazon didn't have these and I had to keep going back to my local pet store to buy them. Obviously Milk Bone is MUCH cheaper than Old Mother Hubbard's treats and I transitioned to them as my dogs' go-to treat for when they go potty. They are perfectly small enough where it's cost efficient for me and just enough for them to satisfy them when I give them this treat.Well fast forward to a few months ago, I came down to my last box of Milk Bone Mini's and thought I'd look at Amazon again. While Amazon now has started carrying the Milk Bone Mini's, they are way overpriced compared to the local store. The Milk Bone Mini's at my local store typically cost around $3.79 for a 15 oz box. Sometimes you can get them cheaper when on sale, but I've had to buy them at full price more often than not. Looking around for S&S items (to get my 20%), I saw that they offered these treats in a 3 lb bag. After 20% off, thee Old Mother Hubbard biscuits are actually CHEAPER than Milk Bone!! Not only that, it's the assortment, which my dogs love.Now it's important to know that the "mini" size that these come in are bigger than the Milk Bone Mini size by at least 200%. I can actually break these in half and it comes around to the same size as a Milk Bone. So I get "double" the treats for a fantastic price.Thanks Amazon!

My 4th box my dogs love them made with good quality ingredients very pleased

My dogs really seem to like this. They’re crunchy and the right size. The perfect incentive to get them to do all the tricks that I need them to do. Especially for rewarding when they have done a good potty.

Love the Old Mother Hubbard bones, but my dogs love them more. Great price and I love feeding them a natural dog treat. I love that there are a variety of flavors. Just the right size for my PeekaPoo and a tasty snack for my Dalmatian. Highly recommend.

This product has been in my family for years. My Goldens love them !! I am always amazed how all the little treats are never broken into little pieces . Great quality control and kudos to the delivery guys too !!

We try to give our dog healthy food although not necessarily the most expensive :-). This seems to have done the trick and never given him a single problem, like some other soft chews did (diarrhea).

I like that these dog biscuits are just the right size for my beagle mix. He loves to catch them.

all mother hubbard products are great

Great little biscuits, perfect size for our little pooch...

Is what I ordered

My dog loves these. I accidentally bought small instead of mini. I have a large black lab, but I like to stick a few in the treat ball that she pushes around. With the small ones, you have to break them up. Slightly inconvenient, but not a big deal. She's happy to have them.

I like the product but will never buy from this seller again. Horrible service, almost a month later, still no product, no way to contact seller and no information on tracking or anything.

This is a great, large-sized treat for a large dog. My dog's a picky eater, too, but she loves these. I wanted a large treat for her to munch on, between meals, but most dog treats are tiny, and I didn't want to get her junk food, like Milkbone. These are a fantastic solution.